How to sell jewelry online: marking rules, listings and fees on Etsy, Amazon and eBay

Contents
  1. When people search how to sell jewelry online
  2. Fine jewelry or fashion jewelry: what changes the rules
  3. What to check before you list jewelry
  4. Where to sell: Etsy, Amazon, eBay or your own store
  5. How to build a jewelry listing
  6. How much you keep from one order
  7. Mistakes that cost the most
  8. When the jewelry catalog comes from supplier price lists
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Sources

To sell jewelry online, first decide what you sell: fine jewelry made of gold, silver or platinum, or fashion jewelry made of base metals. Fine jewelry must be marked and described exactly as the rules require: in the US, "sterling" means at least 925/1000 silver, and a quality mark needs your trademark next to it. Then pick a marketplace — Etsy, Amazon or eBay — and check its category rules and fees.

Mistakes here cost real money: "silver" on a plated earring, a karat stamp without a trademark, an Amazon listing in a category that needs approval, a price that does not cover a 20% referral fee. Below: how fine and fashion jewelry differ, five checks before the first listing, what a listing needs, and how much you keep from one $120 ring on each marketplace.

When people search how to sell jewelry online

Usually it is one of two people. The first makes jewelry or has found a silver supplier and wants to open an Etsy shop or list on Amazon. The second already sells fashion jewelry and is thinking about adding sterling silver, because the price per order is higher. They search for "how to sell jewelry online", "do I need a license to sell jewelry online" and "how much does Etsy take from a $100 sale".

"Which website is best" is the second question, not the first. The first is what exactly you sell: the metal decides how you mark and describe the piece, and on Amazon it decides whether you need category approval. That is the first section.

Fine jewelry or fashion jewelry: what changes the rules

Fine jewelry is made of precious metals — gold, silver, platinum and the platinum group metals — with or without stones. Fashion jewelry (costume jewelry) is made of base metal alloys, steel, glass or plastic. The line runs along the metal, not the price or the look, and almost every requirement below depends on it.

Fine jewelry: quality mark plus trademark, Amazon approval may apply; fashion jewelry: no quality mark, nickel limit
Fine jewelry and fashion jewelry: what differs when you sell online
RequirementFine jewelryFashion jewelry
Quality mark (US)"Sterling", karat or platinum terms only at the fineness the FTC Guides set; a stamped quality mark needs a trademark or name next to itNo quality mark; "gold" or "silver" only for a qualified surface layer such as "gold plated"
Hallmarking (EU)National rules; not harmonised across the EUNot applicable
Nickel and lead (EU)Limits apply to the alloyLimits apply
AmazonCertain types of fine jewelry require approvalSeparate fashion jewelry category
EU 14-day withdrawalApplies, except made-to-order or clearly personalised piecesApplies, with the same exception

Gold plating on brass or steel does not make a piece fine jewelry. If the base metal is not precious, it is fashion jewelry, and calling it "gold" or "silver" without qualification misleads the buyer — the FTC Guides treat unqualified "gold" as 24 karat throughout and "silver" alone as misleading without a fineness mark.

What to check before you list jewelry

Run five checks before the first listing. Each one comes from a law or a marketplace rule, not from a style preference.

  1. The words match the metal (US). Under the FTC Jewelry Guides (16 CFR Part 23), "sterling", "sterling silver" and "solid silver" mean at least 925/1000 pure silver, "coin silver" at least 900/1000. "Silver" on its own is acceptable only with an equally prominent fineness mark right before it. "Gold" without a karat qualifier means 24 karat throughout; gold plate must be at least 10 karat.
  2. A trademark next to the quality mark (US). If a piece is stamped "925", "sterling" or "14K", the National Gold and Silver Stamping Act requires the maker's or dealer's name or a trademark registered or applied for in the US within 30 days of the item entering commerce. Buying from a supplier — check both marks when the batch arrives.
  3. Hallmarking in the country you sell to (EU). Precious metal control is one of the few non-harmonised areas in the EU: each member state has its own rules, and goods move under mutual recognition. Some states also accept the Common Control Mark of the Hallmarking Convention. Check the country profile on the Convention's website before you ship fine jewelry there.
  4. Nickel and lead (EU). REACH Annex XVII limits nickel release to 0.2 µg/cm²/week for posts inserted into pierced ears and 0.5 µg/cm²/week for earrings, necklaces, bracelets, rings and other pieces in direct and prolonged contact with skin. Any individual part of a jewelry article must contain less than 0.05% lead by weight. Ask the supplier for a test report against these limits.
  5. Category rules of the marketplace. Amazon says some types of jewelry require approval, and certain fine jewelry must pass a certification process; you check this per product in Seller Central before listing. On Etsy and eBay, read the category requirements in your seller account before uploading the catalog.
Product tag of a sterling ring: maker, ring, sterling 925, 3.2 g, size 7, cubic zirconia

Business licenses and sales tax registration depend on your state, city or country — check them with the local authority. The federal rules above regulate how you mark and describe the metal, and they apply whichever marketplace you choose.

Where to sell: Etsy, Amazon, eBay or your own store

Each marketplace takes a different cut and asks for different things, so the choice depends on what you sell and at what price. The fees below are the US rates published by the marketplaces.

Marketplace fees for jewelry, US
MarketplacePer-sale feeFixed feesJewelry specifics
Etsy6.5% of the order total incl. shipping + payment processing 3% + $0.25$0.20 per listingRead the category rules in your shop settings
Amazon20% up to $250, 5% above $250 (minimum $0.30)$39.99/month Professional or $0.99 per item IndividualCertain fine jewelry requires approval
eBay15% up to $5,000, 9% above$0.30 per order up to $10, $0.40 aboveStore subscribers pay 13% and 7%
  • A marketplace brings buyers from day one, but takes its fee and wants complete attributes. Amazon's guide for sellers from abroad is in how to sell on Amazon.
  • Your own store has no referral fee, but you pay for traffic. For jewelry it is also where the buyer reads warranty and return terms before paying.
  • Social media show jewelry on people well; orders from Instagram, Messenger or WhatsApp still need the same marking and the same product data.

How to build a jewelry listing

An online buyer cannot hold the piece, so the listing has to answer three questions: what it is made of, what size it is, and whether it is genuine. Each answer is an attribute plus a photo.

Four photos for a jewelry listing: main view, on hand, the stamp close up, next to a ruler for scale
  • Title: type, metal and fineness, stone — "Sterling silver 925 ring with cubic zirconia". For fashion jewelry — the material, with "gold plated" or "silver tone" instead of "gold" or "silver".
  • Attributes from the tag: fineness, weight in grams, size, stone and its weight, plating (rhodium, gold) as a separate field.
  • Four photos: the piece on a light background, on a hand or a person, the stamp close up, the piece next to a ruler.
  • A size chart in millimeters and a tip on how to measure a finger with a string or an existing ring.
  • Returns and warranty: state the return window, and for EU buyers say which pieces are excluded because they are engraved or made to order.

How to shoot jewelry and keep the images light is covered in product image optimization; how to write a description that sells rather than lists — in product description formulas.

How much you keep from one order

You keep the sale price minus the cost of goods, marketplace fees, shipping and the share of returns: You keep = Price − Cost − Marketplace fees − Shipping − Returns per order. Marketplace fees are the only line that changes from one marketplace to another, so calculate them separately for each.

Illustrative example for the arithmetic; cost, shipping and returns are not market figures, the fee rates are the published US rates from the table above. A sterling ring sells for $120 with free shipping, the cost of goods is $60, packaging and shipping paid by you $6. One order in twenty comes back, and each return costs $60 in shipping and repacking — $3 per order. On Amazon the $39.99 Professional plan is spread over 40 orders a month, about $1 per order. Sales tax is left out.

Illustrative example: one $120 sterling ring, one order
LineEtsy, $eBay, $Amazon, $
Sale price120.00120.00120.00
Cost of goods−60.00−60.00−60.00
Percentage fee−7.80−18.00−24.00
Payment processing−3.850.000.00
Listing, order or plan fee−0.20−0.40−1.00
Packaging and shipping−6.00−6.00−6.00
Returns per order−3.00−3.00−3.00
You keep39.1532.6026.00
From a $120 ring on Etsy: cost 60, Etsy fees 11.85, shipping 6, returns 3, you keep 39.15

On the same ring Etsy leaves $13.15 more than Amazon, but the difference comes from fees only — the number of orders each marketplace brings is a separate question. A 20% referral fee on Amazon means a ring that costs you half its price leaves under a quarter of the price. If you buy at more than about 70% of the sale price, the Amazon order barely breaks even in this example. To set prices backwards from the margin you need, use the markup and margin formulas.

Mistakes that cost the most

  • "Silver" or "gold" on plated pieces. The FTC Guides call it misleading; the buyer gets something other than what was described, and the listing collects returns and complaints.
  • A quality mark without a trademark. The Stamping Act requires a name or trademark next to a "925" or karat stamp.
  • Fine jewelry on Amazon without checking approval. Certain types require it; check in Seller Central before you buy stock for that channel.
  • No test report for EU shipments. Nickel release and lead content have hard limits; without a report you cannot show compliance.
  • No weight and no size. The buyer cannot compare price per gram and guesses the size, and that is where returns come from.

When the jewelry catalog comes from supplier price lists

Once you have hundreds of pieces and take prices and stock from several suppliers' price lists, updating Etsy, Amazon, eBay and your store by hand stops working: a ring that is out of stock gets sold, or the price lags behind the supplier.

Elbuz loads supplier price lists on schedule, calculates sale prices by your markup rules, creates listings and updates prices and stock on Etsy, Amazon and eBay, and collects orders from these marketplaces in one list.

Who does not need it: a maker who produces a few dozen pieces and sells them in one channel — the marketplace's own seller account is enough.

Jewelry on marketplaces with ElbuzSupplier price lists, prices and stock on Etsy, Amazon and eBay, 14 days free

Frequently asked questions

How much does Etsy take from a $100 sale?

$9.95 for a US seller using Etsy Payments, if shipping is free and sales tax is left out: a 6.5% transaction fee ($6.50), payment processing of 3% + $0.25 ($3.25) and the $0.20 listing fee.

How much does Amazon take from a $100 jewelry sale?

$20 as the 20% jewelry referral fee, plus either $0.99 per item on the Individual plan or a $39.99 monthly Professional plan. Above $250 the referral fee on the extra portion drops to 5%.

Do I need a license to sell jewelry online?

It depends on your state, city or country: business licenses and sales tax registration are local. For jewelry itself, US federal rules regulate how you mark and describe precious metal — the FTC Jewelry Guides and the National Gold and Silver Stamping Act.

Can I call plated jewelry "silver" or "gold"?

No, not without qualification. The FTC Guides treat "silver" alone as misleading without a fineness mark, and unqualified "gold" means 24 karat throughout; plated pieces are described as "gold plated" or "silver plated".

Is it profitable to sell jewelry online?

It depends on the margin after marketplace fees. In the illustrative example a $120 ring bought at $60 leaves $39.15 on Etsy, $32.60 on eBay and $26.00 on Amazon — calculate the same line by line with your own numbers.

Can EU customers return jewelry bought online?

Yes, within 14 days without giving a reason. The exception is goods made to order or clearly personalised, such as an engraved ring.

Sources

  • FTC Guides for the Jewelry, Precious Metals, and Pewter Industries, 16 CFR Part 23: § 23.3 gold content, § 23.5 silver content — law.cornell.edu.
  • National Gold and Silver Stamping Act, 15 U.S.C. § 297 (trademark with a quality mark) — law.cornell.edu.
  • Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 (REACH), Annex XVII, entry 27 (nickel) and entry 63 (lead in jewelry) — eur-lex.europa.eu, consolidated version.
  • Convention on the Control and Marking of Articles of Precious Metals, "European Union" (non-harmonised area, mutual recognition) — hallmarkingconvention.org.
  • Your Europe, "Returns and the right of withdrawal" (14 days, made-to-order and personalised goods) — europa.eu.
  • Amazon, "Sell jewelry on Amazon" (approval for certain fine jewelry) — sell.amazon.com.
  • Amazon, selling plans and referral fees — sell.amazon.com.
  • Etsy Help, "Etsy Fee Basics" (listing and transaction fees) — help.etsy.com.
  • Etsy Help, "What are Payment Processing Fees for Selling on Etsy?" — help.etsy.com.
  • eBay Seller Center, "Seller fees" (Jewelry & Watches final value fee, per-order fee) — ebay.com.

Checked on November 1, 2026.

Save a link to this article Telegram Facebook X LinkedIn Viber WhatsApp
Learn more about Elbuz with AI Ask your question — pick a chat and let AI study this page for you:

Discussion of the topic – How to sell jewelry online: marking rules, listings and fees on Etsy, Amazon and eBay

0 comments

There are no reviews for this product.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are checked

Next

Try Elbuz free